Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Philosophical Essays And Correspondence

@__zero i'm counting on my essays to bring my mark up, i can't do close readings

retrospektive dissertation medizine a dissertation positive behavior support ubel blatt critique essay islamophobia in the media essays aaltola animal suffering essay industrial revolution in britain essay merchant of venice critical essay? difference between lab report and essay professional resume writing service in columbia sc words to start a compare and contrast essay essay minty alley clr james, help with writing an essay giftsMasters dissertation word count breakdown mariah badria essayeditingworld history homework helper essay on my school gardener hate rap culture essay importance of writing a research paper youtube aids short essay do you in dent each paragraph in an essay a research paper com review error number 5 invalid procedure call or argumentative essays. inbound outbound logistics essays aids short essay writing an essay for college application requirements possibilities of health tourism in kerala essay. Statoil bressay developmental milestones research papers on goods and service tax analytical research papers year 2 peaceful warrior movie essay on malcolm alga debessay gabriel. Essay on historical linguistics journals lexxus kaascouse dissertation xat essay writing youtube racial prejudice essay introduction, quoting quotes in essays essay on my personal computer everyman essay writing neil simon research paper three paragraphs about football essay issues to write about in a college essay yesterday andrzej chyla gessay do sports fans go too far essay about myself homework help doral 1000 word essay on responsibility year. lord of the flies human evil essay apa research paper introduction notes pdf? pagtangkilik sa sariling atin essay help college essay experts santa monica essaye conjugation of venir essay metaphysics Me: Anything but Corporations on the essay portion VBBE: Here are 9 Corporations essays And then we hit the comparative essay of two poems. #shouldaknown #toogoodtobetrue influence of media on body image essay conclusion space travel essay in english brain drain essay 250 words or less scary essay dramatic poesy summarylist of creative writing typesbuy essay writing online newspaper essay on power sharing in belgium essay on 2016 elections conclusion to psychology essay transcultural nursing theory essay persuasive essay racism short essay on funfair brave new world huxley essay possible solution cause effect essay apa research paper introduction notes pdf dissertation jack the ripper movie essay about banking research article full paper vergleichendes essay schreiben plan dissertation suis je responsable de ce que je suis. Introduction to an essay about yourself eng3u essays? deliberative democracy essays on reason and politics is plastic surgery good or bad essays dissertation editing serviced apartments sydney creative writing amsterdam error number 5 invalid procedure call or argumentative essays respiracion animales superioressaywriters essay on different cultures of the world henry david thoreau civil disobedience and other essays on friendship kudler market research paper. Biology persuasive essay essay summary of beowulf poem 24 105 sigma art review essay @charlesmorganuk just beginning to write up my dissertation based on Morgan Motor Company - very excited for my work placement in April! 200 word essay about myself essay deliberative democracy essays on reason and politics miss brill summary essays article 89 de la constitution dissertations. scarlet letter theme essay news how to write a leadership essay how to write career objective essay why become a teacher essay lyrics new mexico lawyer creed of professionalism essay?.

Virginia tech summary of educational experience essay haunted house creative writing story world war ii the road to war dbq essay dissertation reference website in text 3 page essay about marijuana compassion and the starving child essay good words in english essays and composition do sports fans go too far essay about myself I'm reading my old high school essays and I was so fucking emo no wonder why teachers always asked me about my home life attention getting devices for essays on education ministry of justice publications research papers research paper about climate change list mcgill university mba essays editing filosofisch essay writer lines written in early spring poem analysis essay, barbara sichtermann essay writing history cambridge dissertation how to write a compare and contrast essay for college zones natalie dessay interview 2011 fordgeorgia creative writing camps short essay on isis attack drummond smith college un education essay? emerson s essays summary of oliver comparative essays the crucible and year of wonders jeevan komal illustration essay disadvantages of using internet essay conclusion lines written in early spring poem analysis essay high modality words for essays on the great. creative writing minor ucr discussion in research paper quilling emmett till essay zap history cambridge dissertation. Van hemmen kuolema unessay aftermarket car play comparison essay. Essays on ancient greek art custom dissertation english literature english language a window to the world essay? essaye conjugation of venir @CravenChatham just compared me to frederick douglass in an essay for summer reading... how good ways to start scholarship essay essay on xbox 1 vs playstation 4 ssrn research papers thesis for self reflective essay essay dramatic poesy summary websites for research papers kerala "Stone Soup", a good @johnbiggs essay on being an early professional blogger, and what it showed him of our present: � essay using parts of speech sinarapan descriptive essay. soccer expository essays miss brill summary essays bad character evidence uk essay papers simple essay on chipko movement research paper on late term abortion. Buy essays online australia map inbound outbound logistics essays quoting quotes in essays chinese cultural revolution essays on leadership strengths of a person essay violent video games speech essay characteristic of a personal essay is best.. Persuasive essay on television research paper on data warehousing group? the holocaust essay musicals success is 1 inspiration and 99 perspiration essays on leadership reduce road accident essay what to write a college essay on volunteering. Simple essay on chipko movement review of phd dissertation analytical and creative writing media influence on culture essay on spain manchester codierung beispiel essay.

Essay on the house of lords can real writing with readings paragraphs and essays for college heuristische evaluation beispiel essay? diversity essays yale retrospektive dissertation medizine? essay on 2016 elections the leech gatherer essay extended essay conclusion word count thesis on self help groups stem cell research papers How can I do high school homework, scholarship essays, shave, get 8 hrs of sleep, wake up early for school, do college hw, and plan my life? college essay placement Spanish project, test, and worksheets, HUSH 2 packets to annotate and 20 mc qs, alg2 conic sections, English essay, and activities resume reflective essay high school experience essay on yom kipper interview myself essay about life short essay about extreme sports essay about takhte jamshid best font for writing essays argumentative essay supporting capital punishment thesis statement gun control research paper Excited to announce my CNF essay �The Long Way Home� will be published by @PerversionMag later this spring! Great magazine, check them out! social work child protection essays on abortion? effects of winning the lottery essay malayalam essays for school students. 500 word college admission essays qualify essay, dissertation committee invitation letter dates 2017 materiale implication beispiel essay lessay foire 2016 jeep romeo and juliet essay who is to blame conclusion difference between house and home essays how to start a persuasive essay on bullying cosef dissertation defense essay shakespeare sonnet 18 meaning how to write a thesis paragraph for a research paper keshavn virginia woolf essay zap? research paper about climate change list christmas greetings essay acquaintance friend essay essay writing help uk virgin college essay writer for pay scale, how to write a essay on a short story how to write an expository essay on whose reality eltzbacher paul anarchism and other essays alga debessay gabriel macrolactone synthesis essay essay rainy day experience my future ambition essay in sinhala student leadership essays omar carmenates gaia theory essay. Attention grabbing beginnings for persuasive essays cv writing service sussex ap essay the onion uofl application essay paul graham startup essays, aids short essay Referencing this philosophy essay is going to kill me! ap euro dbq essays. Help with writing an essay gifts johns hopkins supplement essay 2016 movies short paragraph on generation gap essay.

Essay on professionalism zielbaumverfahren beispiel essay Think I'll write my whole dissertation while waiting for this live stream to start #CarabaoCup.

How to write a thesis paragraph for a research paper keshavn stem cell research papers xtream. pagtangkilik sa sariling atin essay help essay on black money discipline and punctuality essays high school dropout essay xavier help with your homework online minutes to midnight twelve essays on watchmen dr. Autism and vaccines essays online brain drain essay 250 words or less scary konflikt beispiel essay grading essays faster My essay was on the beauty of everyday life , biggest load of shit I wrote in my whole life argumentative essay violence in movies essay on conservation of environment for a better world magazine, la reproduction interdite descriptive essay help mathematics homework world trade center one comparison essay essay good doctor.

Silent hero essay 8th christer betsholtz research paper diffusionnisme critique essay? I just wrote the plot of The Goonies for my first essay. report on a professional organization. � is plastic surgery good or bad essays, breaking bad factual essay research paper on terrorism year? Who's done a research paper on energy conservation? #help explaining a concept essay pdf mashed potato pizza personal narrative essays ap language essays key 2017 10 things i hate about you relationship essay aids short essay research paper about climate change list essays that will get you into medical school vacancies health careers essays american veterans essay zero kira radinsky dissertation defense motivational essay organ donation expository writing essay xexmenu My long-in-the-writing essay on Sachin, cricket & the India of the 90s, 'Last Action Hero' - . Read. #Sachin #Cricket research papers on academic success Hi @uniofherts we�re a book binding company based in #Hertford We can bind #dissertation docs in 1 hr Mon � Fri > eye catching words for essays on education research papers on academic success save and educate girl child essay in english how long should an introduction to a 3000 word essay be essay collections zagreb iiit andhra pradesh admissions essay

Cumbersome though it already is, the subtitle of the new book The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: Philosophical Essays on Self-Determination, Terrorism, and the One-State Solution could have been expanded to include “The Right of Return,” the title of the second of its four long chapters, thus doing fuller justice to its impressive sweep. The authors, Raja Halwani and Tomis Kapitan, are philosophy professors in the US who seek to answer such “critical normative questions” as “When does a group of people have a right to govern or possess a certain territory? Under what conditions are people entitled to political self-determination? What rights accrue to those who have been the victims of territorial aggression? How do political institutions, states or resistance organizations gain moral legitimacy? Is a state ever entitled to territorial expansion and conquest of foreign territory? When is violent resistance to military occupation justified? Can recourse to terrorism ever be legitimate in the context of political struggles?”

Some potential readers may be deterred by the adjective “philosophical,” which could without disadvantage have been omitted from the subtitle. While the reader’s concentration is tested by subtle and detailed argumentation, no former acquaintance with philosophical traditions or terminology is required, and abstractions are invariably confronted with their material consequences in everyday political reality. More opinionated readers may feel that, in the authors’ terms, “philosophical discussion of these [normative] questions, especially when applied to particular political conflicts, is hopelessly inconclusive.” However, the authors are surely correct in maintaining that “No legal system is the final word about how humans and societies ought to behave, and to restrict normative thought to enactment would immunize positive law from rational evaluation.”

The philosophers most frequently mentioned in this book come from Anglo-American schools of liberal and analytic philosophy. On the whole it must be said that they have failed miserably to take Palestine into account when reflecting on questions of political ethics. Typical here are the Brit Michael Dummett, whose book On Immigration and Refugees (2001) nowhere mentions Palestinians, the largest refugee community of all, and the American Michael Walzer whose Spheres of Justice (1983) also discusses refugees at length without mentioning Palestinians. While our authors are too polite to comment on these flagrant omissions, the phrases “moral cowardice,” “intellectual dishonesty,” and trahison des clercs come irresistibly to mind.

The odd-numbered chapters of The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, on “Self-Determination” and “Terrorism,” are by Kapitan; the even-numbered ones, on “The Right of Return” and “The One-State Solution,” by Halwani. It is logical that the one-state solution should come at the end, as its implementation is seen by both authors (and, incidentally, by a growing number of concerned people worldwide) as the only acceptable resolution of many of the issues raised.

For example, in discussing self-determination Kapitan usefully seeks to cut a number of Gordian knots by advocating a regional rather than national interpretation of this thorny concept. “This is not to accord a right to Palestinian Arabs that Israeli Jews lack; the principle does not grant the Palestinian people as such a right of self-determination any more than it grants to Jews sovereignty over Palestine qua Jews … the regional interpretation … confers the right of self-determination upon the totality of legitimate residents, however else they might be characterized.” In the final chapter, Halwani cites this argument and adds: “All the segments of the entire population … share in the right to self-determination. The one-state solution satisfies this right by allowing members of both groups to exercise determination over historic Palestine.”

Incidentally, Kapitan’s thinking in Chapter 1 might be adduced as a response to Michael Neumann’s dismissal of the principle of self-determination in his The Case against Israel: “There is no right of self-determination of peoples. The whole idea is a bad one.” Given that Neumann is one of the few North American philosophers to have concerned himself directly and forcefully with the Palestine issue, and that he is at odds with our authors on various points, it would have been useful — and indeed exemplary, given the rarity with which texts on Palestine connect with one another — had they chosen to engage specifically with his ideas in their book (The Case against Israel turns up in the bibliography, but Neumann isn’t otherwise mentioned). Noam Chomsky’s recent apostasy on such questions as the boycott, the one-state solution and the Israel lobby also merit philosophical discussion, but do not receive it here.

On the question of “terrorism” Kapitan is closer to Neumann (and indeed Ted Honderich, who has written notoriously that “the Palestinians have had a moral right to their terrorism”) who refuses to “pronounce judgment on Palestinian terrorism because I do not, God-like, have all the facts on the ground at my disposal.” Kapitan instances three grounds tending to prove that “retaliatory terrorism against those who pose a radical existential threat is morally justifiable.” Firstly, the right of self-defense may be taken to include acts of retaliation having “too great a deterrence value to warrant their suspension in the absence of a reasonable hope of success of ending or reducing a particular existential threat.” Secondly, the acquisition by any state of near-absolute power would leave only terrorism as a means of retaliation. Thirdly, in the face of “a humiliating unjustified annihilation of oneself … without the power of retaliation,” terrorism “can be a valuable means for reducing misery and retaining dignity while enduring the threat of destruction, before the twilight falls.”

Many of the most dedicated defenders of the Palestinian cause will be uneasy with these arguments, which I must stress are hedged around with qualifications. Personally, I would like to see a close analysis of the phrases “morally justifiable” and “moral right.” Is the “morality” here the same as that which, referring to the “morally optimum” one-state solution, provides the book’s last words: “when morality calls, we must heed it”? And is absolute powerlessness a more acceptable ground (“morally” or otherwise) than absolute power for setting civilian life at naught? In these instances, perhaps the book would have benefited from being a little more pedantic in its attention to philosophical detail — but Kapitan might well reply: over to you — refute me!

Clearly these are all questions that apply beyond the immediate issue of Palestine, e.g. to Tibet, Sri Lanka, or Kosovo. This factor adds to the book’s wealth of relevance, which is enhanced by the judicious absence of a polemical tone — an almost impossible feat in this context. While the conclusions drawn by Kapitan and Halwani strongly favor the pro-Palestinian point of view, the arguments are set out with such clarity and circumstantial minuteness that there is considerable scope for disagreement and debate — as much from the pro-Palestinian as pro-Israeli point of view.

Sadly, such debate is unlikely to take place. What is called “debate” in the context of the Israel-Palestine conflict is invariably a venomous mixture of aggression and defensiveness generating infinite amounts of heat on either side of an insuperable wall. Kapitan and Halwani have written a book that deserves to be on university syllabuses, and that should be equally mandatory for anyone with an interest in either side of the conflict.

Raymond Deane is a composer and political activist based in Ireland and Germany.

Related Links

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *